Warning Signs in Nonprofit Job Interviews: Lessons from My Experience

As someone with decades of experience in technical writing and grants development, I recently applied for a position as a Grant Writer & Fundraising Specialist. The role seemed promising on paper — working with a federally incorporated nonprofit that claimed to provide training for construction workers.

P.S. Even on Linkedin when you see “HIRING” posts, please be aware that all posts are not genuine.

I was pleasantly surprised to receive an interview invitation almost immediately after applying. But what unfolded taught me an important lesson: not every organization that calls itself a nonprofit is structured or operating in a way that inspires confidence.

I want to share my experience so that others can recognize the red flags in nonprofit job interviews before committing their time, skills, and reputation.

---

✨ The Promise vs. The Reality

On its website, the organization promised training in construction trades — welding, carpentry, block laying, and more. It portrayed itself as a federally registered nonprofit with a mission to empower newcomers and young workers.

But reality told a different story:

• The office address listed online had no sign or suite number, just a generic street address.
• The CEO worked out of a shared office space used by several other startups.
• There was no training facility of any kind — only promises of training, with no evidence of students or graduates.

---

🚩 Red Flags I Noticed

During the interview, a series of red flags became impossible to ignore:

1. No board of directors. When asked directly, the CEO admitted there was no board. This is a fundamental requirement for any legitimate nonprofit.
2. One-person operation. The CEO was running the organization alone, with vague references to “friends” and contacts.
3. Unrealistic funding claims. He insisted he could secure money “with a phone call” and dismissed the importance of organizational legitimacy to funders.
4. No track record. There were no student outcomes, graduates, or examples of completed training programs.
5. Distraction and boasting. Instead of discussing the organization’s needs or my potential contributions, the CEO spoke mostly about his sports connections and businesses overseas.
6. Dismissal of accountability. When I asked about governance, he told me I “knew too much” and that he needed someone who wouldn’t ask those questions.

---

🔍 Why These Red Flags Matter

It is important for job seekers to understand why such warning signs should not be ignored:

• A nonprofit without a board and bylaws lacks accountability and legitimacy.
• Funders — whether governments, foundations, or corporate partners — always require proof of governance, transparency, and community impact.
• Without evidence of programs or results, there is no way to demonstrate the nonprofit is truly serving the community.
• Leaders who dismiss accountability or transparency put both the organization and its employees at risk.

As grant writers, fundraisers, or program staff, our work depends on the credibility of the organization we represent. Without that foundation, even the most skilled professional will not succeed.

---

💡 Lessons for Job Seekers

If you are applying for roles in nonprofits, here are some lessons I took from this experience:

• Research the organization before applying. Look at their website, address, annual reports (if available), and whether they are listed in official nonprofit registries.
• Ask polite but important questions in the interview: Who sits on the board? How is funding currently structured? How many participants have they served?
• Look for transparency. A legitimate nonprofit will be happy to share governance details, financial accountability, and impact stories.
• Trust your instincts. If something feels vague, rushed, or “too good to be true,” it probably is.

---

✅ The Positive Side

Although this interview was not the right fit, I do not consider it a failure. In fact, I see it as a valuable dress rehearsal. It gave me the chance to practice presenting myself after many years, to refine my interview questions, and to reaffirm the standards I want to uphold in my work.

Most importantly, it reminded me that protecting one’s integrity and reputation is just as important as securing a job.

---

🌟 Conclusion

Nonprofits play an essential role in our communities, but not all organizations that call themselves nonprofits live up to the standards of accountability and service.

For job seekers, especially those in fields like grant writing and fundraising, it is vital to recognize the red flags early. Ask the right questions, observe carefully, and never compromise your standards.

A job may provide income, but your integrity is priceless.

By sharing my experience, I hope others will be better prepared to recognize when a nonprofit interview is an opportunity — and when it’s a warning.

---

✍️ Author: Tino Sequeira
Technical Writer | Grants & Proposal Specialist | Advocate for Integrity in Nonprofits

To learn more about how you can maximize your grant application success, (and the comparison between red and green flags), please check my blog: https://right2write.ca/2025/08/28/maximize-your-grant-application-success/